Best Catcher’s Mitts for Players of All Ages

The job of a catcher is one of the most demanding on a baseball team. As a catcher grows in to the position, he will call the pitches, catch each thrown pitch, keep track of base runners, attempt to throw out runners attempting to steal, back up plays at first or third base, cover the plate when throws come in from the field, field fair balls hit directly in front of the plate and chase down foul balls hit near the plate area. Catchers need specialized equipment to be effective and safe behind the plate. Featured below are catcher’s mitts broken into 2 categories, Ages 11 and below, which are considered youth mitts and ages 12 and up, which are considered adult mitts. Listed are the specifications and pricing for several of the most popular catcher’s mitts that offer durability and value. These mitts are the best catcher’s mitts for players of all ages.

Having a proper catcher’s mitt is a must for any player who plays catcher position with any regularity. A catcher’s glove is referred to as a “mitt” because it does not have separate finger pockets as regular baseball gloves do. Catchers mitts tend to be very stiff and take considerable time to break in, which we will cover in detail.

Parts of a catcher’s mitt:

How to measure a catcher’s mitt:

Catcher’s mitts are measured by circumference. The circumference of a catcher’s glove can be anywhere between 29.5 and 34.5 inches. To determine the circumference, measure around the perimeter with a flexible measuring tape. This measurement is the mitt’s circumference, or size.

How to choose the correct size catcher’s mitt:

Typically, anyone ages 7-12 will require a mitt of 32″ or less, while a player who is 13 or older will usually go for a mitt of 32.5″ or more.

Construction materials:

Younger, less experienced players, will likely want a softer material which makes breaking in much easier and quicker which will make it easier to open and close the glove. For these players, a synthetic or pigskin material would be best. These gloves are less expensive, so when a player quickly outgrows the mitt, your investment will have been less.

Players who have already committed to several years in the position, will want a stiffer, more durable material. These players should choose steerhide or full-grain leather mitts.

Breaking in a mitt:

The best way to break in a new glove is by using it. To break in a catcher’s mitt prior to putting it in play, it should be used for practice, warm up or just playing catch. Alternatively, it could be used catching balls thrown by a pitching machine. Another effective way to break in a catcher’s mitt is by using a glove mallet. One of the most functional and economic models is the Rawlings Glove Mallet ($11.95 at Baseball Express) Using a mallet for a few minutes each day to simulate repeatedly catching a ball which will soften the leather and help form the pocket.

Glove conditioner and an over sized ball and strap used repeatedly when the glove is not in use will form the pocket and soften the leather. Taking these steps will assure that your new glove is properly broken in. There are many products available. One of the best all-inclusive kits with all the items necessary are included in the Rawlings Glove Break-in Kit ($8.95 at Baseball Express)

Maintaining the mitt:

To keep your glove clean and prevent the leather from drying out, a glove conditioner should be used 4 times a season. Glove conditioners do not soften the leather. Catching a baseball (or using a mallet) softens the leather. A conditioner is used to maintain the glove for years of use. There are many glove conditioners on the market. One of the best I have found is Rawlings Gold Glove Butter ($6.95 at Baseball Express) which was designed for higher-end gloves but works well on any glove – old or new.

Making sure the glove is properly broken in prior to use will enhance the functionality and give the player greater confidence.

Each of the mitts featured below can be ordered in left-hand throw (mitt is worn on the right-hand) or right-hand throw (mitt is worn on the left-hand). The link for each glove is for a right-hand throw. If you need a left-hand throw model, you can easily make that selection on the order page. I have listed the age group that each mitt is appropriate for.

I have checked the prices at all major distributors, the prices I have listed are the lowest current prices available. I check all pricing regularly to make sure that the best possible value is listed for you here.

A good mitt will last your player for many years. I have listed gloves in each category in multiple price ranges. Your players enjoyment of the game will be greatly enhanced if they have safe, functional and properly sized equipment.

Please feel free to email me directly if you have specific questions that are not answered here. You can reach me at

Please visit my other baseball equipment pages for players of all ages by clicking the following links:


This post contains affiliate links. An affiliate link means that I may earn a referral fee if you purchase products through one of my links, without any additional cost to you.  

I am a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to and affiliated sites.

Youth (Age 7-11) Catcher’s mitt recommendations:

Easton Paragon 31″ Youth Catcher’s Mitt

New for the 2019 baseball season! Calling all avid younger ball players! The Easton Paragon Series was made specifically for a youth hand. The Paragon is built with a Select Cowhide palm and leather shell. Go even further into the details and you’ll find cowhide laces which reinforce the pocket, web and fingers. The super soft palm lining enhances a player’s grip for better control while making those big plays. This Easton Paragon is a terrific option for any young player behind the dish.

  • 31.00 Inch Pattern
  • One-Piece Solid Web
  • Colors: Black / Brown
  • Game Ready Feel
  • Rawhide Laces Reinforce Pocket, Web, & Fingers
  • Select Cowhide Palm & Shell Leather
  • Super Soft Palm Lining Enhances Grip For Better Control
  • Youth Catcher’s Mitt

Check Lowest Price Here                                                                                                                                                                                                                     Shop all Catcher’s Mitts

Rawlings Renegade 31.5″ Baseball Catchers Mitt

2019 brings in a new series, the Rawlings Renegade design is ideal for players of all ages and all skill levels as they are available in both adult and youth pattern sizes. With a durable all leather shell and lacing, these mitts are extremely durable and will hold their shape for a very long time. A deep, well-formed pocket design ensures that you will have ball security every step of the day. Additionally, high-density palm and finger pads add much-needed comfort and protection that any player would want and need. Plus, the cushioned finger back and fastback design allows for added flexibility and strength. If you’re looking to improve your performance at an affordable price, the Rawlings Renegade is the design for you.

  • 31.50 Inch Pattern
  • Break-In: 20% Player, 80% Factory
  • Colors: Black / White
  • Deep Pocket For Ball Security
  • Excellent Quality At An Affordable Price
  • Fastback Design
  • Sure Catch Heel Design Provides A Quick & Easy Close
  • High Density Leather Palm For Added Comfort
  • Index Finger Hood For Added Protection
  • Leather Shell & Lacing For Maximum Durability & Pocket Formation
  • Oil-Tanned Full Grain Leather For A Game-Ready Feel
  • One-Piece Solid Web
  • Speed Trap Design For Easy Closure

Check Lowest Price Here                                                                                                                                                                                                                    Shop all Catcher’s Mitts

Mizuno Prospect Series 31.5″ Youth Catcher’s Mitt

Mizuno is known for making it their priority to develop ball gloves for every age and skill level. The Prospect Series is tailor made to fit a young ball player’s hand. Multiple technologies make it easier for younger players to close the glove, catch the ball and learn to love the game. These gloves help youth players catch the “right” way, in the pocket. Mizuno’s patented PowerClose technology places “hinges” where players would close the glove to make squeezing the ball and making the catch as simple as can be! Inside the glove, a ParaShock Palm Pad reduces all shock caused by impact and leaves the player’s hand sting-free! This mitt also utilizes a conventional open back with a narrower wrist opening to create a snug, comfortable and custom feeling fit for every player. This 31.50 Inch catcher’s mitt is a full-sized youth pattern and features a two-piece closed web to make snagging any kind of pitch as simple as possible.

  • 31.50 Inch Pattern
  • Youth Model – Smaller Hand Openings and Finger Stalls for Ideal Youth Fit
  • Butter Soft Palm Lining
  • ParaShock Palm Pad – Outstanding Protection Through Less Rebound and Less Shock
  • Patented PowerClose Technology and V-Flex Notch Make Catching Easier
  • Two-Piece Closed Web
  • Conventional Open Back

Check Lowest Price Here                                                                                                                                                                                                                   Shop all Catcher’s Mitts

Under Armour Deception Series 31.5″ Youth Catchers Mitt

From innovative sports apparel to ultra-high end protective equipment, the Under Armour crest can be seen emblazoned on the gear worn by some of the world’s best athletes. And now that passion to create better athletes through design has led to the development of their Pro, Deception, and Framer Series catcher’s mitts. With its high quality leather construction that allows for a quicker break-in, the Deception Series UACM-200Y was designed specifically for the demands of elite Travel Ball players and features a 31.50 Inch Pattern and a smaller fit that is perfect for the hands of Youth or Intermediate age catcher’s. Each Under Armour catcher’s mitt features a very wide, deep pocket that creates the perfect target for pitchers and improves the catcher’s ability to receive the ball efficiently. With such a deep pocket, some may have concerns about securing the ball on close plays at the plate, but the thicker heel and toe padding that the Deception Series offers ensures that the baseball stays securely in the mitt. These mitts are also insanely durable. Inside, PTH Padding runs the length of the palm to prevent sting and also improves the longevity of the leather where it experiences the most wear and tear. And with a vertically laced web and pocket, the chances of a snapped lace or worn web is greatly reduced.

  • 31.50 Inch Pattern
  • Conventional Open Back
  • Steerhide Leather Construction – Exceptionally Durable but Allows for Quick Break-In
  • Designed for Elite Travel Ball Players
  • Perforated Back Reduces Weight while Retaining Durability
  • PTH Padding – Absorbs Ball Impact and Extends the Life of the Mitt
  • Thicker Heel and Toe Pads – All for Perfect Receiving and Keeps the Ball in the Pocket
  • Vertically Laced Two-Piece Closed Web
  • Wide, Deep Pocket
  • Youth Model – Smaller Hand Openings and Tighter Finger Stalls Optimize Fit for Young Hands

Check Lowest Price Here       


Wilson 31.5” Youth A360 Series Catcher’s Mitt

Give your young one a secure fit and a professional, broken-in feel with the Wilson® 31.5” Youth A360™ Series Catcher’s Mitt, featuring a full pigskin leather palm and synthetic backing for ultimate flexibility.

  • Full pigskin leather palm and web offers the perfect combination of durability and softness for ultimate value
  • Synthetic backing offers ultimate flexibility and a broken-in feel right from the start
  • Half-Moon Web’s small pocket ensures extremely responsive transfers to the throwing hand
  • Hook and loop closure
  • Conventional open back
  • Long-lasting durability and professional feel

Check Lowest Price Here                                                                                                                                                                                                                   Shop all Catcher’s Mitts

B45 Diamond Series 31.5″ Custom Youth Catcher’s Mitt

Also available in 33″ and 34″ sizes

Professional PRO pattern designed by insights from the B45® Advisory Staff, the 31.5″ Diamond Series Glove is the choice of professionals because of unmatched feel, rugged durability and perfect break-in. Diamond Series Leather is made with Korean tanned steerhide leather. Pretty easy to break-in and ready to hit the field.

  • Absolute Quality: unquestionable, we will always provide with you the best quality out there. Always.
  • Customer Satisfaction: we are committed to deliver a customized experience that will lead to the best product for you.
  • Refinement and Sophistication: to always improve ourselves drives us on a daily basis.
  • Series: Diamond
  • Customizable colors
  • Available for both Right-hand Throw and Left Hand Throw
  • High Quality Korean Leather
  • Specs: Size: 31.5″
  • Baseball Position(s): Catcher

Exclusively Available From B45 Baseball – Check Lowest Price Here                                                                                                                                 Shop all Baseball Gloves

adidas 31.5″ Youth Triple Stripe Series Catcher’s Mitt

Durability and elite performance sets the 31.5’’ adidas Triple Stripe Catcher’s Mitt apart, with a soft cowhide palm and leather back which adds greater flexibility for young players learning the finer points of the position. Crafted For Excellence: Durable, soft leather construction offers a game-ready feel Adjustable wrist closure provides a custom fit for youth players Sleek desert camo design Conventional open back.

  • Size: 31.5”
  • Age: Youth
  • Sport: Baseball
  • Position(s): Catcher
  • Web: Closed
  • Color: Brown Desert Camo

Check Lowest Price Here                                                                                                                                                                                                                    Shop all Catcher’s Mitts

Adult (Age 12-Adult) Catcher’s mitt recommendations:

Rawlings R9 Series 32.5″ Catcher’s Mitt

New for 2019! Rawlings would like to introduce the never before seen Rawlings R9 Series baseball lineup. These all-new R9 Series baseball gloves are the best gloves on the market at this price point. This series features soft, durable all-leather shells with an 80% factory break-in for a game ready feel, so you won’t have to commit a lot of time to break this catcher’s mitt in. Inside this R9 Series mitt, you will find padded fingerback liners and a padded thumb loop for added comfort. This R9 Series glove is perfect for the Select Player in the 8-14 age range playing behind the plate.

  • 32.50-Inch Pattern
  • Break-In: 20% Player, 80% Factory
  • Colors: Black / Brown / Grey
  • Conventional Back
  • Designed For Select Players 8-14 Years Old
  • New R9 Series
  • Catcher’s Model
  • Quick, Easy Break-In For A Game-Ready Feel
  • Reinforced Palm Pad
  • Reinforced Thumb Loop
  • Season After Season Durability
  • Shell: Soft, Durable All-Leather
  • 1-Piece Solid Web

Check Lowest Price Here                                                                                                                                                                                                                   Shop all Catcher’s Mitts

Marucci BR450 Series 32.5″ Catcher’s Mitt

Marucci catcher’s mitts are available in all shapes, sizes, and colors. For the 2018 season, the BR450 series is a great option for adult or intermediate players looking for a game ready mitt with minimal break in required. Built with genuine steer hide leather, these baseball mitts offer a quick break in period without sacrificing exceptional structure. Each model meets professional grade standards and is skillfully and individually handcrafted for a precise, custom fit on every player. Marucci has placed internal padding along with fabric finger back linings inside of each glove for additional protection on defense and a soft, luxurious feel. The different web designs throughout the BR450 series are all approved by Marucci’s player advisory board made up of Major League ball players. Not to mention, professional level USA tanned lace helps hold each baseball mitt together for multiple seasons.

  • Colors: Brown / Camel / Red
  • Conventional Open Back
  • Fabric Finger Back Linings Offer A Soft, Luxurious Feel
  • Catcher’s Glove
  • Genuine Steer Hide Leather Creates A Quick Break In Period
  • Index Finger Pad
  • Medium-Deep Pocket Pattern Construction
  • Professional Level USA Tanned Lace Provide Superior Structure
  • Two-Piece Closed Web
  • Skillfully & Individually Handcrafted For A Custom, Precise Fit
  • Soft Internal Padding Delivers Exceptional Protection
  • Web Design Approved By Marucci’s Player Advisory Board

Check Lowest Price Here                                                                                                                                                                                                                    Shop all Catcher’s Mitts

Wilson A1000 33″ Catcher’s Mitt

Catch every pitch and never pass a ball when guarding home with this 2019 Wilson A1000 catcher’s mitt. The new A1000 series features soft but durable Pro Stock leather, so you don’t have worry about long break-in times before game day. Hear the solid sound of a fastball hitting the mitt with the sturdy and soft construction that conforms to your hand without sacrificing on impact protection. The leather interior is sturdy and supple for structure and comfort where you need it most. Game-ready materials mean you’re ready for the plate from the moment you pull on the mitt.

  • Half Moon Web
  • Colors: Grey and Black with Red
  • Velcro Back
  • 33.00 Inch Catcher’s Mitt
  • Pro Stock Patters
  • True Pro Stock Feel Captures The Feel Of An A2000 But Game-Ready
  • Sturdy & Soft For Strength Where You Need It & Softness Where You Don’t
  • Full Grain Leather
  • All Leather Shell
  • Rawhide Laces & Leather Lining

Check Lowest Price Here   


Rawlings Heart of the Hide 33″ Catcher’s Mitt

New catcher’s mitt for the season and beyond! The world-renowned name “Heart of the Hide” says it all because the leather that is used for each mitt is cut from the top 5% of the center on the steer hides Rawlings has available. Laced together by the Tennesse Tanning rawhide results in unparalleled durability and strength. Not only will you be getting one of the most dependable and reliable catcher’s mitts out there but the padded palm, padded thumb sleeve, and soft full-grain finger back lining provide top-notch comfort and extra protection during impact. Additionally, each model offers a 30% factory break-in so that the player break-in period is nowhere near as time-consuming. Worn by a number of Gold Glove Award winners, the Heart of the Hide catcher’s mitt has been the cornerstone of those deemed “The Finest in the Field” and are now available to elite players looking to improve and define their defensive greatness.

  • 33.00 Inch Pattern
  • Authentic Professional Pattern
  • Break-In: 80% Player, 20% Factory
  • Colors: Black / Brown / Tan
  • Conventional Open Back
  • Heart of the Hide Traditional Leather Shell – Cut From Top 5% Of Rawlings’ Hides
  • One-Piece Solid Web
  • Padded Thumb Sleeve
  • Soft Full-Grain Finger Back Lining Provides Unbeatable Feel
  • Tennessee Tanning Rawhide Leather Laces – Adds Structure, Durability, & Strength
  • XRD Palm & Index Finger Padding Provides Top Notch Protection Behind Home Plate

Check Lowest Price Here                                                                                                                                                                                                                   Shop all Catcher’s Mitts

B45 Pro Series 33″ Custom Youth Catcher’s Mitt

Also available in 34″ size

Professional PRO pattern designed by insights from the B45® Advisory Staff, the 31.5″ Diamond Series Glove is the choice of professionals because of unmatched feel, rugged durability and perfect break-in. Pro Series Leather is made with Japanese tanned steerhide leather. Durable and stiff glove that makes it the perfect choice for the top players.

  • Absolute Quality: unquestionable, we will always provide with you the best quality out there. Always.
  • Customer Satisfaction: we are committed to deliver a customized experience that will lead to the best product for you.
  • Refinement and Sophistication: to always improve ourselves drives us on a daily basis.
  • Series: Pro
  • Customizable colors
  • Available for both Right-hand Throw and Left Hand Throw
  • High Quality Japanese Leather
  • Specs: Size: 33″
  • Baseball Position(s): Catcher

Exclusively Available From B45 Baseball – Check Lowest Price Here                                                                                                                                    Shop all Baseball Gloves

Mizuno Classic Pro Soft 33.5″ Catcher’s Mitt

Mizuno has a new Pro Soft Catcher’s Mitt for 2019! The Classic Pro Soft series offers professional patterns for the best players across the world in every position. Whether you are an infielder, an outfielder, a first baseman, or even a catcher behind home plate, this particular design is a great option that can’t be beaten. It all starts with Mizuno’s Throwback leather that provides a rugged and rich feel. This leather is naturally pre-oiled so that each baseball glove breaks in quickly while still retaining shape over time. Roll welting assists with that shape retention by contributing to the stability through the fingers while also contributing to the overall look of the ball glove.

  • 33.50 Inch Pattern
  • Catcher’s Glove
  • Colors: Camel / Brown
  • Conventional Open Back
  • Outlined Mizuno Patch
  • Two-Piece Closed Web
  • Throwback Leather – Rugged, Rich, & Naturally Pre-Oiled For Softness & Retains Shape Over Time
  • Pro Grade Laces For Improved Strength

Check Lowest Price Here       


Easton Flagship Series 33.5″ Catcher’s Mitt

Protect your plate like never before with this 2019 Easton Flagship Series catcher’s mitt. Pre-treated with oil for a faster break-in time, this catcher’s mitt has a DIAMOND PRO STEER leather shell that stands up well to repeated use, and the classic cowhide lining provides an excellent feel for the ball and keeps the player’s hand comfortable. This Flagship Series catcher’s mitt from Easton has split-grain leather welting, which increases durability at the seams, adds structure and strength, and reinforces the shape of the mitt. This Flagship Series catcher’s mitt also makes sure you look good crouched behind the plate thanks to the classic brown leather color and contrasting stitching.

  • Diamond Pro Steer Leather Shell
  • Oiled Classic Cowhide Palm & Finger Stalls
  • 33.50 Inch Pattern
  • Colors: Brown / Natural
  • One-Piece Solid Web
  • Designed For Maximum Comfort
  • Split Grain Leather Welting For Extra Stength
  • Pro Grade Rawhide Laces For Extra Durability
  • Steer Hide Binding Increases Overall Glove Longevity
  • Luxurious Sheep Wool Wrist Liner
  • New Flagship Series

Check Lowest Price Here                                                                                                                                                                                                                   Shop all Catcher’s Mitts

Wilson A2K SuperSkin 33.5″ Catcher’s Mitt

Protect the backstop with greater confidence with this 2019 Wilson A2K SuperSkin baseball glove. Designed with a double-palm construction, this glove offers maximum pocket stability to help the ball stay put during close calls at the plate. The large size of the pocket offers an easy target for the pitcher, and the thick padding protects the hands from fastballs or foul tips. Manufactured with Pro Stock Select leather, this mitt is soft to the touch for maximum flexibility, and the rolled dual welting helps the glove stand up well to a grinding season.

  • 33.50 Inch Mitt Size
  • Catcher’s Glove
  • 3X More Master Craftsman Shaping Helps Reduce Break In Time
  • Conventional Open Back
  • Double Palm Construction Provides Maximum Pocket Stability
  • Dri-Lex Wrist Lining Offers Ultra-Breathable, Moisture Wicking Material
  • Pro Stock Select Leather Comes From Top 5% Of Wilson Hides
  • Quicker Break In Compared To An All Leather A2K
  • Rolled Dual Welting Creates A Perfect Pocket With Long Lasting Shape
  • SuperSkin Helps Lighten The Glove, Repel Moisture, & Is 2X Stronger Than Traditional Leather

Check Lowest Price Here                                                                                                                                                                                                                     Shop all Catcher’s Mitts

Mizuno MVP Prime SE 34″ Catcher’s Mitt

The MVP Prime Special Edition baseball mitts are the result of industry leading innovation combined with color pop designs that are bound to make you stick out of the diamond. Constructed out of smooth, professional grade Bio Soft leather, these catcher’s gloves maintaining their structure over a much longer period of time and require next to no break in period. To boost the long-lasting durability and superior structure, Mizuno uses the same professional level lace that’s offered in their professional level gloves. But, inside of each model is where the magic really happens. An ultra comfortable Steer Soft palm liner provides additional padding and a smooth, buttery soft feel that improves both comfort and control.

  • 34.00 Inch Pattern
  • Bio Soft Leather Construction Provides A Long Lasting Structure With Minimal Break In
  • Catcher’s Glove
  • Color Pop Designs Help You Stand Out On The Diamond
  • Conventional Open Back
  • Outlined, Embroidered Mizuno Logo
  • Pro Scoop Helps Dig Baseballs Out Of The Dirt
  • Professional Level Laces Are The Same Quality Offered In Mizuno’s Pro Gloves
  • Two-Piece, Closed Web

Check Lowest Price Here                                                                                                                                                                                                                     Shop all Catcher’s Mitts

Wilson 34” A2000 SuperSkin Series 1790 Catcher’s Mitt 2019

The 34″ Wilson A2000 1790 SS takes the most popular MLB catcher’s mitt pattern and adds Black SuperSkin for a light, long-lasting glove with a great break-in. This model features an extended palm to reduce rebound as well as a wider web and stiffer thumb. A Dri-Lex wrist lining helps move moisture away from your skin to keep you cool and comfortable through every inning.

Constantly improving patterns. Materials that perform. Dependable construction. The evolution of the A2000 baseball glove has been driven by insights from the Wilson Advisory Staff. This is why hard-working players love its unmatched feel, rugged durability and perfect break-in.

  • Crafted from Pro Stock American steerhide leather
  • Man-made SuperSkin makes glove stronger and lighter
  • Dual welting helps glove maintain shape and creates a durable pocket
  • Dri-Lex moisture-wicking wrist lining helps keep hand dry
  • Velcro wrist strap provides a snug, secure fit
  • Thumb protector offers extra comfort
  • Size: 34″
  • Position: Catcher
  • Web Pattern: Half Moon Web
  • Back: Open

Check Lowest Price Here                                                                                                                                                                                                                   Shop all Catcher’s Mitts

Rawlings HOH ColorSync 3.0 34″ Baseball Catcher’s Mitt

The Limited-Edition Heart of the Hide® ColorSync™ 3.0 gloves offer a whole new spectrum of color to match your unique style. These new leather and color combinations are truly a thing of beauty. Constructed from Rawlings’ world-renowned Heart of the Hide® steer hide leather, Heart of the Hide® gloves feature the game-day patterns of the top Rawlings Advisory Staff players. These high quality gloves have defined the careers of those deemed “The Finest in the Field”®, and are available to athletes looking to join the next class of defensive greats.

  • Conventional back features a wide opening above the wrist
  • Authentic Pro patterns
  • Tennessee Tanning pro lace
  • Deer tanned cowhide “plus” palm lining
  • Rolled leather welting
  • Soft leather finger back lining
  • 1-Piece Solid-Web
  • 34″ Catcher’s Mitt

Check Lowest Price Here                                                                                                                                                                                                                   Shop all Catcher’s Mitts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Visit Us